Mainstream lenders set the standard
Jake Sandford, head of data and analytics at Smart Money People, reveals that brokers now judge lenders primarily on end-to-end experience.
Our H2 2025 Mortgage Lender Benchmark results reflect a market where brokers are placing growing importance on the overall experience, covering the clarity, speed and reliability that are central to every case journey.
In this edition, mainstream lenders led the way with a Broker Experience Index of 72.4 – a notable uplift on H1 and the strongest performance across any sector. Many mainstream lenders have invested heavily in digital optimisation while maintaining consistent business development manager (BDM) support, helping them deliver the most dependable end-to-end broker journeys.
Buy-to-let lenders also performed strongly with a Broker Experience Index of 72.1, continuing to stand out for their online tools and systems (4.17).
Meanwhile, building societies maintain a competitive position with a Broker Experience Index of 71.2. While their overall scores have softened compared to previous editions, they continue to excel on relationship-led service, reflected in strong BDM satisfaction and communication.
Elsewhere, later life lenders achieved a Broker Experience Index of 69.2, scoring well for affordability, clarity and customer support.
Although speed is behind other sectors, brokers note that many later life providers continue to balance caution with care, ensuring suitability on more sensitive client profiles.
Commercial and bridging lenders (68.3) show steady performance, with strong satisfaction around overall service and BDM support. While processing speeds remain slower, brokers highlight the value of specialist expertise in navigating non-standard or time-sensitive deals.
Specialist lenders continue to score below the market average, with a Broker Experience Index of 64.1. Lower satisfaction with speed and online systems remains a challenge, although brokers still note the sector’s importance for clients with more complex circumstances.
All in all, the sectors combining reliable processing, strong communication, and supportive human touchpoints continue to deliver the best broker experiences.
How do lender types differ?
Broker feedback continues to fall into three broad categories – people, product and lending, and process – and our latest MLB shows a clear pattern in how frequently these areas are mentioned and how positively brokers view them.
Process-related feedback dominates the verbatim, making up 61.9% of all comments. However, it also carries the lowest sentiment score at 69.7, showing that the day-to-day operations of working with lenders remain the biggest causes of friction. Process issues continue to have the strongest influence on overall experience.
Product-related themes account for 24.0% of broker feedback, with a sentiment score of 75.6, the highest across all groups. Brokers often highlight strengths in product suitability, criteria, and range – with relatively low levels of negative feedback.
Criteria (8.1%) continues to be the most discussed product-related area, with sentiment at 75.4, followed by strong scores for product range (80.1) and flexibility (79.5). Clarity of criteria (albeit a smaller share of comments), remains highly valued when present.
Some of the lowest sentiment themes sit within operational areas such as valuations (63.4), communication (60.0) and legals (40.0), where delays and poor visibility continue to affect broker trust.
People-based themes represent 14.2% of all feedback, and sentiment remains strong at 72.0. Brokers continue to value supportive BDMs, helpful underwriters, and responsive customer service teams and BDMs (72.0) and customer service (71.5) remain important strengths across many lenders. Skill and knowledge, although mentioned infrequently, is one of the highest-rated themes at 83.9.
Even as digital tools improve, it’s clear that human support remains a major source of strength for many lenders. Especially in complex or time-sensitive cases.
Jake Sandford is head of data and analytics at Smart Money People












